Based on your analysis you have a good idea of what buyer type will be interested in acquiring your company. But how will that buyer type value your business? Before we consider that, let’s review the valuation methodologies. The following is a brief overview of the valuation process. A complete understanding of business valuation would require a college course at the MBA level!
You should note that valuing a business is not an exact science. Even the best appraisers need to make subjective decisions in the valuation process. Consequently, business valuations for the same company can vary from appraiser to appraiser.
There are 3 fundamental approaches to valuing a business. They are:
- Market Approach – This works best in Real Estate because there are so few parameters to consider, and they are fairly consistent by region and price range. Businesses, on the other hand, have an almost infinite number of “moving parts”, so that comparable sales have to be used in conjunction with other valuation methods. The problem with employing this approach to private SMBs (Small and Medium sized Businesses) is that there’s not enough data to compare “apples to apples”. This method is probably better suited to valuing public companies where a large amount of data can be gleaned.
- Income Approach – The Income approach may be the most common for valuing private SMBs. As expected, it is based on company revenues and earnings. One method is called “Multiple of Discretionary Earnings Method (SDE)”, where the SDE is defined as the net operating income plus adjustments plus the owner’s salary. The multiple is the inverse of the capitalization rate (cap rate) which is determined from an analysis of the Another method, the “Discounted Value of Future Cash Flows”, is based on “reasonable” projections (usually 5 years), and uses a “discount rate” (usually the cap rate plus rate of growth) to calculate the Present Value of the future cash flows.
- Asset Approach – This approach is used when the Fair Market Value replacement cost of assets represents most, if not all, of the value of the Obviously, it is based on the hard assets of the business, the machinery, equipment, furniture and fixtures, etc. It’s typically used when the business is no longer a going concern, or if the business has been losing money for the last few years.
Let’s look at the most likely valuation methods used by each buyer type:
- Strategic Buyer –These are typically large private or public companies. By their very nature Strategic Buyers are interested in how the acquisition of your company can benefit them in the future, and they are not so concerned about what your company has done in the past. Consequently, the most likely valuation method will be the Discounted Value of Future Cash Flows.
- Sophisticated Financial Buyer – These buyers are typically small investment groups, Private Equity Groups (PEGs), and small companies interested in growth by acquisition. These buyers are interested in what your company has done in the past, as well as opportunities for growth in the future. Consequently, the most likely valuation methods will be the various Multiples of Earnings (using EBIT and EBITDA) and the Discounted Value of Future Cash Flows.
- Lifestyle Buyer – These buyers are looking for an income, the ability to build equity, and the ability to service their debt from future cash flows. There is a saying about this buyer type “they will buy the future but they will only pay for the past”. If they are looking at 3 companies and everything else is equal except for the “future” prospects, they will buy the company that presents the best opportunities. Consequently, the valuation method of choice for this buyer type is the Multiple of Seller Discretionary Earnings. For larger companies still within this buyer type segment, they may use the Multiple of EBITDA. The only difference between the two is that Seller Discretionary Earnings includes the owner’s salary and Multiple of EBITDA does not.
- Industry Buyer – don’t confuse the Industry Buyer with the Strategic Buyer. The Industry Buyer is usually somebody in your niche that you know and considers your company inferior to his company. He’s typically a “bottom feeder” and is trolling for a company that he can buy on the cheap for certain assets that your company may have. If he uses a valuation method it will be the Asset Approach – probably a Book Value method. If there’s any possibility that this particular buyer may be interested in buying your company (total assets plus goodwill), then you must seek professional help to even the playing field.
The valuation methods used by the buyer types presented above are certainly not cast in stone. In any given situation any buyer type may use several different valuation methods. If a buyer uses several different valuation methods, there significance is typically weighted and the valuation methods by buyer type suggested above usually receive a higher weight.